As Gotham FC walked off the Icahn Stadium pitch following Sunday’s 2-1 semifinal defeat to the Kansas City Current, there was a feeling in the air that significant roster changes would soon follow.
Two pillars of the Bats’ success are reportedly set to depart the club as free agents.
On Monday morning, Jenna Tonelli of Sports Illustrated reported that veteran defender Jess Carter will sign as a free agent with Bay FC.
Hours later, Megan Feringa and Melanie Anzidei of The Athletic reported that all-world goalkeeper Ann-Katrin Berger will not renew her contract with Manchester City, among clubs chasing the 36-year-old’s signature.
Gotham FC Face New Era Between the Posts With Berger Departing

Berger finished as runner-up for the Yashin Trophy and is a finalist for NWSL Goalkeeper of the Year. Back in August, Gotham FC assistant goalkeeper coach Michelle Betos explained the difference that Berger makes with her incredible game-reading ability and shot-saving abilities.
“I think that Ann is exceptional,” Betos told South Ward Central. “I think there’s probably not a category she wouldn’t be pretty high up in, but I think two of the things that make her truly special and able to play at the level she’s playing at for so long are her ability to read the game, both on the ball and off the ball.”
“Ann probably could be up for Save of the Week once a week or every other week, but I think it’s actually the stuff she does before a save that really, really makes her that top one percent in the world. Her ability to read the game is not like anyone I’ve truly encountered thus far.”
Gotham Will Miss Carter’s Reliability

Carter has been a model of dependability since she joined Gotham partway through the 2024 NWSL season. Her calming influence in defense was particularly critical over the past two seasons as the Bats‘ backline endured long-term injuries to captain Tierna Davidson, Emily Sonnett, Bruninha, Mandy Freeman and Kayla Duran.
The 29-year-old England international was the glue that held the backline together amid injuries and roster changes. She rarely put a foot wrong and excelled in 1v1 defending.
“Jess is one of the best center-backs in the world,” midfielder Jaelin Howell said after Gotham’s quarterfinal victory over Seattle Reign FC. “Her positioning is spot on. She saves us all the time. Jess is so smart with how she defends.”
Gotham Under Pressure to Replace Berger and Carter

Gotham FC president of soccer operations Yael Averbuch West will need to bring in some fresh faces, particularly at central defense and full-back with Carter on her way out. Mandy Freeman and Midge Purce are pending free agents, and Sonnett, Bruninha and Duran are expected to need long spells to recover from knee injuries, though Duran has participated in light on-field drills in recent weeks.
Once Carter walks out the door, Davidson is Gotham’s only center-back who is healthy and under contract.
As for the goalkeeper position, Gotham have capable options who are ready to step in. Berger’s understudy Shelby Hogan recorded three shutouts in her three NWSL appearances this season.
The club also has high hopes for 22-year-old netminder Teagan Wy, who did not make an NWSL appearance in her 2026 rookie season.
“I think over the couple of years, Teagan will be a really good goalkeeper,” Berger stated earlier this month.
Ryan Campbell is currently on loan at Lexington SC of the Gainbridge Super League through December, and Lexington has the option to extend the loan for an additional six months.
Time will tell if Gotham can acquire talents who are capable of replicating the massive contributions that Berger and Carter supplied to the Bats in lifting four trophies and pushing the club to new heights.
If you enjoyed this story, please consider supporting independent, local soccer journalism by buying me a coffee.
Contributions made through Buy Me a Coffee help support the time, travel and resources that go into bringing you on-the-ground coverage, reporting and original stories — without paywalls.
More Gotham FC Coverage
Enjoyed this story? Follow us for the latest updates! | Bluesky | Twitter | Instagram | Facebook


Leave a Reply